Difference between revisions of "What does "unary operator expected" mean"

From Linuxintro
imported>ThorstenStaerk
imported>ThorstenStaerk
Line 2: Line 2:
 
When you work with Linux scripts on the command line, you will sometimes get an error message saying
 
When you work with Linux scripts on the command line, you will sometimes get an error message saying
 
  unary operator expected
 
  unary operator expected
And you may wonder what this means. To give you an example, let's write a short bash script.
 
  
= The script =
+
This means that there is a comparison where one site is empty for example
Just copy and paste the lines below into a Linux Shell:
+
  if [ $name = "Thorsten" ]
[[cat]] >test.sh<<EOF
+
and $name is empty. Then the bash shell will replace $name by an empty string and it will be interpreted as
[[echo]] "how is your name? "
+
  if [ = "Thorsten" ]
read name
+
and this is not a valid expression.
  if [ $name = "Thorsten" ]; then echo "I know you"; fi
 
EOF
 
chmod 777 test.sh
 
After you did this, you have a script test.sh that will ask you for your name and say "I know you" if your name is Thorsten. You can call the script using the [[command]]
 
./test
 
Now if you don't enter a name and just press enter you will get this:
 
# ./test.sh
 
how is your name?
 
 
./test.sh: line 3: [: =: unary operator expected
 
This is clearly a problem in line 3. $name is replaced by ''nothing'' when the shell executes the line. So the remainder of the line reads
 
  if [ = "Thorsten" ]; then echo "I know you"; fi
 
Which does not work because you cannot compare ''nothing'' with "Thorsten".
 
  
= The solution =
+
The solution is to quote the variable names like this:
There is a simple trick to avoid this kind of error messages already when programming. For example if you add an "x" left and right next to the equal sign in line 3:
+
  if [ "$name" = "Thorsten" ]
  if [ x$name = "xThorsten" ]; then echo "I know you"; fi
+
Then it will work.
The shell may still replace $name by ''nothing'', but then the x will stay and the command will be after evaluation:
 
  if [ x = "xThorsten" ]; then echo "I know you"; fi
 
And there will not be an error message any longer.
 
 
 
= If this happens to you ... =
 
This happened to me with a real script from mldonkey, mldonkey_command. Analyzing the script I could find I did not give any paramters to it.
 
  
 
= Shell scripting tutorial =
 
= Shell scripting tutorial =
 
Try the [[shell scripting tutorial]] to avoid this mistake and similar ones in the future.
 
Try the [[shell scripting tutorial]] to avoid this mistake and similar ones in the future.
  
= Outlook =
+
= Debugging bash scripts =
 
You can also debug the script line-by-line using bash -x. bash -x shows all commands that are being executed, just like [[gdb]] or [[strace]], but for bash scripts:
 
You can also debug the script line-by-line using bash -x. bash -x shows all commands that are being executed, just like [[gdb]] or [[strace]], but for bash scripts:
 
<pre>
 
<pre>

Revision as of 19:09, 16 December 2014

When you work with Linux scripts on the command line, you will sometimes get an error message saying

unary operator expected

This means that there is a comparison where one site is empty for example

if [ $name = "Thorsten" ]

and $name is empty. Then the bash shell will replace $name by an empty string and it will be interpreted as

if [ = "Thorsten" ]

and this is not a valid expression.

The solution is to quote the variable names like this:

if [ "$name" = "Thorsten" ]

Then it will work.

Shell scripting tutorial

Try the shell scripting tutorial to avoid this mistake and similar ones in the future.

Debugging bash scripts

You can also debug the script line-by-line using bash -x. bash -x shows all commands that are being executed, just like gdb or strace, but for bash scripts:

tweedleburg:~ # bash -x test.sh 
+ echo 'how is your name? '
how is your name? 
+ read name

+ '[' = Thorsten ']'
test.sh: line 3: [: =: unary operator expected

See also